Would you like to receive notifications on latest updates of the following headlines?

Google faces new antitrust lawsuit  ... after ruling declares search engine illegal monopolist

POSTED ON September 10, 2024 •   Technology      BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara
The Google sign is shown on one of the company's office buildings in Irvine, California, US, October 20, 2020. l Photo Credit: REUTERS/Mike Blake

One month after a judge declared Google's search engine an illegal monopolist, the tech giant faces another antitrust lawsuit that threatens to break up the company, this time over its advertising technology.

The Justice Department, joined by a coalition of states, and Google each made opening statements on Monday to a federal judge who will decide whether Google holds a monopoly over online advertising technology, The AP reported.

The regulators contended that Google built, acquired and maintained a monopoly over the technology that matches online publishers to advertisers.

Dominance over the software on both the buy side and the sell side of the transaction enables Google to keep as much as 36 cents on the dollar when it brokers sales between publishers and advertisers, the government contended in court papers.

They alleged that Google also controls the ad exchange market, which matches the buy side to the sell side.

“It's worth saying the quiet part out loud,” Justice Department lawyer Julia Tarver Wood said during her opening statement. “One monopoly is bad enough. But a trifecta of monopolies is what we have here.”

Google said the government's case was based on an internet of yesteryear, when desktop computers ruled and internet users carefully typed precise World Wide Web addresses into URL fields.

It said advertisers now are more likely to turn to social media companies like TikTok or streaming TV services like Peacock to reach audiences.

In her opening statement, Google lawyer Karen Dunn said, “We are one big company among many others, competing millisecond by millisecond for every ad impression.”

Revenue has actually declined in recent years for Google Networks, the division of the Mountain View, California-based tech giant that includes such services as AdSense and Google Ad Manager that are at the heart of the case, from $31.7 billion in 2021 to $31.3 billion in 2023, according to the company's annual reports.

The trial that began Monday in Alexandria, Virginia, over the alleged ad tech monopoly was initially going to be a jury trial, but Google maneuvered to force a bench trial, writing a cheque to the federal government for more than $2 million to moot the only claim brought by the government that required a jury.

The case will now be decided by US District Judge Leonie Brinkema, who was appointed to the bench by former President Bill Clinton and is best known for high-profile terrorism trials including that of September 11 defendant Zacarias Moussaoui.

Brinkema, though, also has experience with highly technical civil trials, working in a courthouse that sees an outsize number of patent infringement cases.

The trial in Alexandria, Virginia, over the alleged ad tech monopoly was initially set to be a jury trial, but Google maneuvered to make it a bench trial by paying the federal government over $2 million.

The case will now be decided by US District Judge Leonie Brinkema, who has experience with highly technical civil trials.

The Virginia case comes after a major defeat for Google over its search engine, which was declared a monopolist.

The government's witnesses in the Virginia trial are expected to include executives from newspaper publishers.

Google has disputed that it charges excessive fees compared to its competitors.

The company also asserted the integration of its technology on the buy side, sell side and in the middle assures ads and web pages load quickly and enhance security.

It said customers have options to work with outside ad exchanges.

Google said the government's case was improperly focused on display ads and banner ads that load on web pages accessed through a desktop computer and failed to take into account consumers' migration to mobile apps and the boom in ads placed on social media sites over the last 15 years.

The government's case "focuses on a limited type of advertising viewed on a narrow subset of websites when user attention migrated elsewhere years ago," Google's lawyers wrote in a pretrial filing. "The last year users spent more time accessing websites on the 'open web,' rather than on social media, videos, or apps, was 2012."

The trial, which is expected to last several weeks, is taking place in a courthouse that rigidly adheres to traditional practices, including a resistance to technology in the courtroom.

Cellphones are banned from the courthouse, to the chagrin of a tech press corps accustomed to the District of Columbia trial to tweeting out live updates as they happen.

Even the lawyers, and there are many on both sides, are limited in their technology.

At a pretrial hearing on Wednesday, Google's lawyers made a plea for more than the two computers each side is permitted to have in the courtroom during trial but Brinkema rejected it.

"This is an old-fashioned courtroom," she said.

READ ALSO
Federal Ministry Unveils Digital Village to Bridge Digital Divide in Abuja Community
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara May 30, 2025 0

The Federal Ministry of Communications, Innovation and Digital Economy has launched a Digital Villag...

READ ALSO
FG Unveils Project CNG-SPROUT to Revolutionize Campus Transport with Clean Energy
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara May 30, 2025 0

The federal government has launched a transportation initiative called "Project CNG-SPROUT," designe...

READ ALSO
Agro Alliance Takes Top Honors at Hack4Livestock with IoT Solution for Cattle Intrusions
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara May 24, 2025 0

ABUJA, Nigeria - The Ministry of Livestock Development has announced its intention to empower 1,000...

READ ALSO
INEC Launches AI Division to Enhance Electoral Processes, Address Challenges
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara May 23, 2025 0

ABUJA, Nigeria - The Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) has sanctioned the establishme...

READ ALSO
Legal Obligations Remain Despite Threats to Exit Nigeria, FCCPC Rebukes Meta Platforms
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara May 3, 2025 0

The Federal Government, through its Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC), has crit...

READ ALSO
Digital Inequality in Africa: High costs, infrastructure gaps leave millions offline
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara April 21, 2025 0

Despite significant investments in Nigeria and various regions of Africa, only 38 percent of the pop...

READ ALSO
CBEX unregistered digital assets exchange in Nigeria, SEC warns of investment risks
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara April 19, 2025 0

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has announced that Crypto Bridge Exchange, also referre...

READ ALSO
NDPC launches initiative to combat cyberbullying, financial fraud through data protection
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara April 7, 2025 0

The National Data Protection Commission (NDPC) on Monday reiterated its dedication to enhancing data...

OUR CHANNELS:

NEMA Mobilizes Teams to 15 States Amid Flood Warnings
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara June 5, 2025 0

The National Emergency Management Agency (NEMA) has sent officials to 15 high-risk states to educate...


Edo Faces Diphtheria Outbreak, Two Confirmed Deaths
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara June 5, 2025 0

EDO, Nigeria (NAN) - A diphtheria outbreak has been confirmed in Edo State, resulting in two deaths....


Tinubu Honors Bill Gates with National Award for Global Philanthropy
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara June 5, 2025 0

LAGOS, Nigeria - President Bola Tinubu commended Bill Gates, the co-founder of Microsoft and chairma...


Bahrain, Colombia, DRC, Latvia, and Liberia Join UN Security Council for 2026-2027 Term
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara June 5, 2025 0

The UN General Assembly on Tuesday elected five new non-permanent members to the UN Security Council...


Tinubu Orders Urgent Repairs on Flood-Damaged Bridge in Mokwa
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara June 5, 2025 0

NIGER, Nigeria (NAN)- President Bola Tinubu has instructed the Federal Ministry of Works to repair t...


Nigeria Needs ₦2.2 Trillion to Eliminate Cervical Cancer by 2030, Says Task Force Chair
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara June 5, 2025 0

ABUJA, Nigeria — Nigeria will need ₦2.2 trillion to roll out comprehensive cervical cancer ini...


EFCC Charges Two Men for Posing as Fake Sureties in Illegal Mining Case
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara June 4, 2025 0

The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) has charged two individuals, Shehu Abdu and Isah...


Court Sentence Scrap Seller to 12 Years for Sexual Assault of Four-Year-Old Girl
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara June 4, 2025 0

A scrap seller, Nasiru Usman, was sentenced to 12 years in prison by an Ikeja Sexual Offences and Do...


70-Year-Old Faces Manslaughter Charges After Fatal Accident
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara June 5, 2025 0

LAGOS, Nigeria - A 70-year-old man, Isiaka Afolayan, has been detained for careless driving and the...


Police Arrest 49 years old Suspect for Abduction of Two-Month-Old Baby
BY Abiodun Saheed Omodara June 5, 2025 0

DELTA, Nigeria - The police in Delta reported the arrest of a suspect named Joy Temitope for the abd...


More Articles

Load more...

Menu